In mid-February, one of President Trump’s economic advisers walked into the Oval Office with a set of charts. They showed household incomes rising, retirement accounts climbing and the economy growing faster than projected. “This is great stuff,” the president said, according to a Nov. 4 account in The Wall Street Journal by Josh Dawsey, Alex Leary and Lindsay Wise.
At the time, Mr. Trump controlled both chambers of Congress, and the Journal described the Democrats as a party in disarray. Nine months later, as The Associated Press reported, voters handed Democrats the House and the Senate, including Senate seats in Texas, Kansas and South Carolina.
The midterms were a vote of no confidence in Donald Trump’s leadership of the Party of the Extreme Right, which I call POTER, but they did not end that party. Mr. Trump threw away a commanding position one decision at a time, yet a large share of Americans still voted Republican, and the hard right still runs the party. Anyone who thinks the problem left Washington with the Republican majorities is mistaking a lost election for a changed party.
The trouble started before the war. In January, on an icy Minneapolis street, a Border Patrol officer shot Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old intensive-care nurse, in the back. Stephen Miller and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem called Mr. Pretti a “domestic terrorist,” the Journal reported.
Within weeks, Mr. Trump replaced Ms. Noem, and corruption allegations soon surfaced from her time running the department. In the Journal’s words, the immigration crackdown that helped elect him had become an albatross.
Days after that February meeting, the president, who had campaigned on ending foreign wars, launched one of his own against Iran. According to the Journal, the conflict has since killed more than 20 American servicemembers, cost taxpayers more than $47 billion and pushed gasoline prices up 40 percent.
When advisers warned him in the spring that the war could cost Republicans in November, he told them there was plenty of time to figure it out. When they raised voters’ worries about affordability, a senior administration official told the Journal, he called the polling fake.
Matt Walsh, a conservative commentator, told the Journal that the war was “the greatest political blunder in the last two decades.” In his view, it betrayed the America First movement that had put Mr. Trump back in office.
The war landed on an economy already squeezed by tariffs, which are taxes collected on imported goods. In the national exit poll reviewed by National Review, 66 percent of voters said the tariffs had hurt the economy.
The damage reached deep into his own base. Ronald Brownstein wrote in Bloomberg Opinion that in crucial states, nearly half of white voters without college degrees disapproved of the president’s performance. Those voters are the heart of the Trump coalition.
The costs piled up overseas as well. Former Senator Jeff Flake of Arizona told McKay Coppins of The Atlantic that the president’s trade deals were “in tatters” and that allies no longer trusted the United States. Susan Glasser of The New Yorker listed his approach to Ukraine and Vladimir Putin among the grievances voters carried to the polls.
The war in Ukraine has not ended. The Journal reported that Mr. Trump was so desperate to bring down fuel prices that he made a deal with Russia.
He also kept picking fights inside his own party. At a Georgia rally, he called Gov. Brian Kemp “disloyal” and “a bad guy.” When Senate Republicans later asked Mr. Kemp to run for the Senate, he turned them down, saying he would have to disagree with a president who demanded fealty.
Meanwhile, the president’s attention kept drifting to a new White House ballroom, a proposed 250-foot triumphal arch and gold lettering for the Rose Garden. In focus groups described to the Journal, voters who rarely follow Washington news said, “He doesn’t really care about what I’m going through.”
On the eve of the election, he spoke for nearly an hour at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool. Most of the speech covered his renovations of the capital, and he said there was not enough time to discuss his plans for the nation.
Then there were the candidates. The Journal reported that Mr. Trump pushed aside stronger Senate contenders in Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina and Texas in favor of people he believed would be loyal to him. Democrats won all four states.
In Texas, Senate Majority Leader John Thune warned that it would cost $200 million to $300 million to carry Ken Paxton across the finish line. The president replied, “The base is behind Paxton.”
Voters saw it differently. According to the AP Voter Poll, about two-thirds of Texas Senate voters said Mr. Paxton lacked the character to be a senator, and about 6 in 10 South Carolina voters said Darline Graham lacked the experience.
“It really didn’t have to be this way,” Representative Ralph Norman of South Carolina told the Journal. Mr. Norman lost the Republican nomination to Ms. Graham after Mr. Trump stepped into the race.
Voters judged the administration the same way. The National Review exit poll analysis found that 62 percent believed the president put his own interests ahead of the country’s. A separate National Review analysis reported that his personal net worth grew by well over $2 billion in the first 22 months of his second term.
With only two real choices on the ballot, many Americans picked the party they disliked less. The AP Voter Poll found that about half of voters viewed the Democratic Party favorably, compared with about 4 in 10 for the Republican Party. Rep.-elect Dan Koh told Politico that “people voted against Donald Trump far more than they voted for Democrats.”
None of this means the Republican Party has changed. In October, I wrote in this space that Mr. Trump did not build POTER but took temporary command of it. The weeks since the election have shown how little the party itself has moved.
House Republicans responded to their defeat by choosing Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio as their leader. The president then named Mr. Miller, the architect of his immigration crackdown, as White House chief of staff.
Stephen Collinson of CNN noted that the Democratic wave swept many moderate Republicans out of swing districts. What remains is a smaller House Republican conference that is more conservative and more loyal to Mr. Trump.
The voters behind POTER are still there, too. Roll Call reported that white evangelicals backed Republican candidates 82 percent to 17 percent, and that voters without a college degree still leaned Republican by a point. A Reuters/Ipsos poll released Nov. 16 found that about three-quarters of Republicans still like the president, even with his overall approval at 32 percent.
Political scientist Theda Skocpol told The Hankyoreh, a leading South Korean newspaper, that Trump loyalists now run virtually every state Republican Party. She added that the anger fueling the movement is “not going away.”
At a Christian nationalist conference in Texas, CNN’s Donie O’Sullivan reported, the white nationalist streamer Nick Fuentes told the crowd, “The midterms were a rejection of Donald Trump. They were not a rejection of Trump-ism.”
Some conservatives believe the collapse goes deeper than one man. Rod Dreher told Vox, “That MAGA is over.” In a conversation published by The New York Times, Timothy Carney said there is “no juice left to squeeze from MAGA.”
They have numbers on their side. A Politico poll found that 45 percent of voters who call themselves MAGA described their own movement as a loser in the midterms. Reuters reported that activity on the movement’s main online forum had fallen 27 percent since January.
These critics are right that the movement has lost its momentum and the broad coalition that carried it to power in 2024. They are wrong to assume that a movement without its leader is also without members, institutions and control of the party. Mr. Dreher himself warned that extremists would seek influence “in the rubble,” and Ms. Skocpol noted that it usually takes three election defeats to remove a force that controls a major party.
The loudest voices on the right are not debating whether to carry on. They are debating who will lead them next. As Mr. Walsh told the Journal, “We’re going to have to find a new leader because Trump abandoned it.”
POTER is alive and well, and the far left of the Democratic Party is intact as well. The Journal noted that Democrats spent this cycle contending with a rising far left that called for abolishing the police and defunding the Defense Department.
If America sat down to dinner tonight with ten guests, three would still arrive wearing red and three would still arrive wearing blue. The other four would come dressed in lovely shades of purple, and they are the ones who will decide where this country goes next.


